Book Editors

Whodunnit? 8 Mystery Editors for Your Next Chilling Novel

The allure of a mystery novel lies not just in its intricate plot twists and suspenseful turns, but also in its finely honed narrative that keeps readers on the edge of their seats. Behind these gripping tales, there’s a mastermind at work, not of the crime, but of the craft: the editor. 

These literary detectives dive deep into the heart of a manuscript, sifting through clues and red herrings, ensuring every reveal is perfectly timed and every secret is well-guarded until the right moment. In this post, we spotlight some of the industry’s top mystery editors, let’s tip our hats to the individuals who make our favorite whodunits truly unforgettable.

1. Leya Booth

Leya Booth is a seasoned editor with a flair for true crime, self-help, and dark fiction. Based in Milwaukee, WI, she brings over a decade of professional experience, having worked on a diverse range of genres from memoirs to horror. Leya’s approach to editing is collaborative and respectful, ensuring authors’ voices are honored while elevating the quality of their work. She believes in offering gentle critiques and positive encouragement, ensuring every book reaches its full potential. Beyond traditional editing, Leya can assist with transcribing handwritten or typed documents onto a computer and proofreading audiobooks. Esteemed authors like Eric Miller, Harry Shannon, and Paul Levine have lauded her meticulous attention to detail and unparalleled expertise. In her downtime, Leya enjoys spending time with her feline companions and indulging in jigsaw puzzles.

2. Louise Buckley

Louise Buckley, based in London, is an Editorial Consultant with a rich background as a Literary Agent. She boasts extensive editorial experience, having collaborated with both trade publishers and individual authors. Louise’s expertise spans across various fiction genres, including literary and commercial fiction, historical fiction, crime, thrillers, and more. Recognizing the challenges authors face during the writing process, she offers invaluable feedback that can transform a good book into an excellent one. With her deep understanding of the literary world and her commitment to nurturing authors’ visions, Louise is adept at providing the constructive insights authors need to refine their manuscripts to perfection.

3. Dominic Farrell

Dominic Farrell, based in Toronto, ON, is a seasoned editor with over 15 years of experience in the literary world. He has edited a vast array of genres, including fiction, mysteries, history, political science, memoirs, and more. Dominic has a commendable track record, having edited more than 100 titles, some of which have become bestsellers and award winners. He is known for his collaborative approach, always respecting the author’s voice and vision while offering clear and honest advice. Authors have praised Dominic for his patience, respect, and meticulous attention to detail. With a deep understanding of the nuances of storytelling, Dominic is the go-to editor for authors seeking to elevate their manuscripts.

4. Hamzah Hussain

Hamzah Hussain is a London-based editor and proofreader, renowned for his work on best-selling crime and literary fiction, with a specialization in developmental edits. Hamzah’s editorial journey is enriched by his collaborations with esteemed publishers such as Saraband, Peepal Tree Press, Little, Brown Book Group, and Bookouture. He has played a pivotal role in bringing titles by authors like Patrica Gibney, Rahul Raina, and Merryn Allingham to publication. With a keen eye for detail, Hamzah offers invaluable structural and line edits, ensuring manuscripts resonate with readers. His passion particularly lies in crime fiction and thrillers, always on the lookout for the next jaw-dropping, twisty narrative.

5. James Abbate

James Abbate, based in New York, NY, is a professional editor with over a decade of experience, dedicated to preparing manuscripts for publication. As an Associate Editor at Kensington Publishing, he has specialized in a plethora of fiction and nonfiction genres. James has collaborated with both domestic and international bestselling authors, ensuring their works shine with polish and precision. His portfolio boasts titles that delve into the legacies of iconic franchises like “Scarface” and “The Exorcist,” as well as biographies of renowned figures such as Gene Krupa and Keith Urban. With a keen eye for detail and a comprehensive skill set, James is adept at transforming manuscripts into masterpieces.

6. Jayne Lewis

Jayne Lewis, hailing from Harpenden, UK, is a professional and adaptable copy editor and proofreader known for her impeccable concentration, accuracy, and attention to detail. With over a decade of experience, Jayne has honed her skills working on a diverse range of fiction, notably in the crime genre, including titles by best-selling authors. Her background in marketing for blue-chip leisure companies has equipped her with a unique perspective on content creation. Jayne’s editorial prowess extends to both fiction and non-fiction, with works ranging from JFK narratives to explorations of Studio Ghibli. Her dedication to excellence ensures that every manuscript she touches is refined to its utmost potential.

7. Matt Henderson-Ellis

Matt Henderson-Ellis, based in Evanston, IL, is an NYC-trained editor with a rich background from Doubleday. He brings to the table over 25 years of editorial expertise, specializing in manuscript assessment and developmental editing, particularly in genres like crime, true crime, mystery, horror, and memoir. Matt has collaborated with both New York Times best-sellers and award-winning indie authors, covering a spectrum from military fiction to neo-noir crime novels. His approach is comprehensive, focusing on aspects like plot pacing, character development, and ensuring descriptions are vivid and engaging. As a published novelist himself, Matt understands the intricacies of the writing process, making him a valuable ally for authors aiming for excellence.

8. Robin Seavill

Robin Seavill, based in Bristol, England, boasts two decades of experience in commercial fiction and non-fiction, collaborating with renowned publishers such as HarperCollins, Virgin, Harlequin, and Little, Brown. Passionate about helping authors craft the finest versions of their work, Robin’s expertise spans from basic grammar to intricate character development and plot structuring. He has worked with notable authors like David Solomons, known for “Not Another Happy Ending,” and Robert Thorogood, the creator of the TV series “Death in Paradise.” With accolades from Adam Nevill and numerous satisfied clients, Robin’s editorial finesse ensures that every piece he touches resonates deeply with readers.


Behind every spine-tingling mystery, there’s a mystery editor who’s mastered the art of suspense and revelation. As we conclude our exploration, let’s remember and appreciate these guardians of intrigue, who ensure every page we turn is filled with anticipation and awe.